Even though I had to make 600 {yes, you read that right} cupcakes yesterday, I really wanted them to taste homemade. After a couple of you left comments on my Albertsons shopping trip post on how I could improve a boxed mix cake I thought I’d give a few of them a try. And guess what? I liked them all.
Here are a few of the tricks some of the readers suggested:
- “I throw in a box of instant pudding mix {to match the cake mix flavor} when I make cakes from a box. I think it makes the cake more moist and less box-tasting.” – Kathy
- “Add an extra egg to each cake mix and use milk instead of water, if called for, to make the cake taste more like homemade.” – Kelli
- “I often add a cup or less of sour cream to my cakes or cup cakes to make them moist and a tsp or more of real vanilla on top of the regular directions.” – Helen in Merdian
All AWESOME ideas. Plus, here’s a few more to get that “just like Grandma makes it” goodness:
- Use full-fat coconut milk in place of the liquid in any cake mix.
- Use melted ice cream {about 2 cups} in place of oil and water. Experiment with different flavors of ice cream–they all add something different to cake mix.
- Add 2 Tbsp. Mayo to any mix. {My neighbor does this!}
- For Chocolate or Devils Food Cake mixes, use brewed coffee in place of the water. {Just make sure the coffee isn’t still hot first.}
- For yellow cake mix, substitute fruit juice for the water and add a little zest or shredded fruit to the mix. {i.e. orange juice and orange zest or apple juice and shredded apples.}
How about you, do you have any more tried and true shortcuts to getting a boxed cake mix to taste homemade?
~Mavis
This post may contain affiliate links. These affiliate links help support this site. For more information, please see my disclosure policy. Thank you for supporting One Hundred Dollars a Month.